One of my Twitter friends asked me a question today, and it kind of got me thinking. She wanted to know if there was ever a point when you should just scrap a manuscript.
Hmmm. Let me think about that for a moment.
The Big Question
Who among us has never felt the frustration of conceptualizing a manuscript, plotting, planning, and writing it to the point that we are absolutely certain it will CHANGE THE WORLD, only to discover that it just doesn’t work?
No doubt, many of us have.
Case in point: My 2013 NaNoWriMo project. As a writer, I was in a phase where I wanted really complicated plot twists and character relationships, and on top of that, a few of the plotlines and characters would span the time/space continuum. I am befuddled just thinking about that beast.
I got about a third of the way through writing it (from an outline, no less) and found that I couldn’t make it work out the way that I was sure it would when I plotted it months earlier. That manuscript was taking on a life of its own, and as its “parent”, I just couldn’t keep up with it! If there was ever a time for me to consider scrapping a manuscript, it was then.
But I didn’t.
I have mentioned this in other posts on this blog, but writing, as are all of the arts, is a living thing to me. The process of writing is fluid and morphing, and the books we read become part of us, as we live and breathe, taking on a life of their own. Instead of scrapping that beast of a manuscript, I trunked it; I gave it, and me, a Time-Out for a while. That manuscript needed to think about was wrong with it. I needed time away from it as well, to perhaps come up with a plan to better usher that particular Book-Baby into the world with a little more finesse.
Just an FYI, that Book Baby is still in Time Out. It’s been months. Neither of us has figured out what is wrong yet but someday we will. I can’t give up on it. It is a story which has a wonderful heart and deep feeling, but in its current state it’s just too unruly. With a little thought and hard work, I feel like my Book-Baby will become a beautiful thing. Perhaps giving it a name will help (wink, wink!)
I don’t know how long it’s Time-Out will last. It could be years. And who knows. Maybe it’s supposed to be more than one book, or maybe something in the universe was telling me that I am not ready to write that story…yet. It is definitely a “something”, because I still get chills of excitement when I think about it.
So, My Answer To The Big Question:
I wouldn’t scrap a manuscript altogether. Like the unnamed Book-Baby in my example above, I would give it a Time-Out, long enough for the two of us to iron out our differences.
A Few Questions For You:
How do you deal with unruly manuscripts? When they don’t work out as planned, how long before you set it aside? Have you ever scrapped a manuscript completely?
Share your response in the comment section!
Thanks for stopping by my Writer’s Block!